Jump to content

189 vs. 489


dowsieboi

Recommended Posts

Hey all,

Am new here so this is my first post :)

So basically I've just been trying to do some research on the different available visas as I'm still not 100% sure I want to start the whole process yet. The 2 I've been looking at are mainly the Skilled Independent (189) and the Family Sponsored Skilled Regional (489).

So my current situation is that I'm 25, have a BSc. Honours degree in Comp. Sci & Informatics and almost 3 years working experience. Based on the skilled independent I think I had the required 60 points but what I've been trying to figure out is what is the advantage of family sponsorship? I have an Aunt, Uncle and cousin who have Australian citizenship but all I've been able to find so far is that it gives you an extra 10 points on your application. It also limits your ability to work in other regions for the 1st 2 years and it's not permanent.

So I'm wondering if I've missed something? Or is more a case of people will often go for the 189 visa first and fall back to the 489 if they don't have sufficient points?

Thanks in advance for the replies, any advice is appreciated :)

- Michael

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

From a visa holders point of view the SC189 is far preferential to a family sponsored SC489.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hi dowsieboi, welcome to the forum and good luck with the rest of your research and planning.

Listen to them, the 189 is the golden ticket (like the one Willy Wonka gave out, rare and sought after) if you have enough points and is definitely the preferred option. IMHO family sponsorship just creates unnecessary stress in an already extremely stressful process for both parties. Based on your age, work experience, qualifications and if you can score 8+ in all four bands for the IELTS then you should be able to score more than just 60 points won't you? Have you gone through the points test on the immi site?

http://www.immi.gov.au/Visas/Pages/189.aspx

https://www.acacia-au.com/skilled-migration-points-test.php

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hi dowsieboi, welcome to the forum and good luck with the rest of your research and planning.

Listen to them, the 189 is the golden ticket (like the one Willy Wonka gave out, rare and sought after) if you have enough points and is definitely the preferred option. IMHO family sponsorship just creates unnecessary stress in an already extremely stressful process for both parties. Based on your age, work experience, qualifications and if you can score 8+ in all four bands for the IELTS then you should be able to score more than just 60 points won't you? Have you gone through the points test on the immi site?

http://www.immi.gov.au/Visas/Pages/189.aspx

https://www.acacia-au.com/skilled-migration-points-test.php

Thanks for the advice guys :)

Just tried that Migration points test and if I get an 8+ in the English proficiency test then I'd get 65. Miss out on a few of the points when in comes to "Overseas work experience" and "Australian work Experience". Kind of weird that they don't even take in account my "South African work experience"? Unless that falls under "Overseas work experience"?

So looks like the 189 is the way to go :) I've been trying to plan a LSD to see if I would actually want to go but seems like a bit of a toss up between saving for a trip and between saving for the actual visa and maybe even a migration agent to help >.<

Link to comment
Share on other sites

You can put your 3 years work experience under the overseas work experience category which will get you a couple of extra points, 5 if I'm not mistaken.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Welcome to the forum dowsieboi.

It sounds like you are going to be okay with the visa. I hope so but I'm not that familiar with that visa. Sounds like you are getting good advice already.

I was wondering whether you've ever been to Australia before, and what your motivation is to consider the move?

All the best with your decisions.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Welcome to the forum dowsieboi.

It sounds like you are going to be okay with the visa. I hope so but I'm not that familiar with that visa. Sounds like you are getting good advice already.

I was wondering whether you've ever been to Australia before, and what your motivation is to consider the move?

All the best with your decisions.

Thanks :)

I haven't properly been across. Went once to Adelaide when I was young but I honestly can't remember anything about it. This is why I was thinking of doing a LSD sometime towards the end of the year. Am struggling a bit to save up for everything since obviously saving up for a LSD would mean I wouldn't saving up for things like a visa.

So far I've got a few reasons for wanting to move. I haven't had too much exposure to anywhere outside of South Africa so I'm really keen to try somewhere new :) The other reasons are probably the more commonly shared ones where there's always a worry within South Africa. Am I going to get mugged at the next robot? How bad is the economy going to get over the next 5 to 10 years? Would I want to raise a family? Because of my age and the fact I'm not married, it seems like a better time than any to be considering these things. In terms of why Australia, well I've got some family there already so that's already 1 point; climate being close to South Africa and it seems like there's a relatively good quality of life there. Other countries I was considering were Canada or maybe New Zealand. America I have mixed feelings about so it's quite my first choice and Europe seems like it might be too much of an adjustment outside of England?

I'm still struggling a bit though to come to that final conclusion though of whether I want to go or not. Such a massive life decision >.< I'm hoping if I did go on a LSD then that might help persuade me a little more :)

Edit: Just noticed I was logged in on my other account >.< Made a 2nd account cause the dowsieboi 1 first had an error registering and then sat at the approval state for about 2 weeks :/

Edited by S1ght
  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

It's tough when you're doing well in SA and there are only a few 'push' factors and no 'pull' factors.

I tend to see emmigration as a bit of a life experience. I just think life's too short to spend in one place.

If I were you I'd do a lot of research on job availability and things that suit your interests in Aus. An LSD is not a necessity if you're happy to take a slight risk, but great if you have the spare $$. At least you can save a lot of money by staying in backpackers or AirBNB.

Good luck with everything :)

Edited by Bronwyn&Co
  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hi,

My husband was far from convinced and the LSD made it a lot easier to convince him. But Aus is very easy to live in, so I am sure if it's something you are honestly considering then put your money towards the visa... Once you have it you have a year to decide if you come for a LSD or to make the big move. I would get on to the visa ASAP... Rules may change and you may miss out on the opportunity. You can always decide to stay in SA and call it a bad investment but I doubt you will feel that way!

Welcome and all the best.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

@dowsieboi

Welcome to the forum! You are going to find a lot of help on here, everyone is awesome at giving advice (as you've already seen!)

Definitely go for the 189. I am also 25 and qualified as a CA last year, also have 3 years work experience. Submitted my EOI with 65 points and received an invite the next week :)

If you have the capital now to invest in the visa then I say do it, even if you're not 100% sure yet. That's what you should view the visa as - an investment. Who wouldn't want the chance to jump ship in SA and head for greener pastures if (when) things start going south?

You're looking at spending around R40k in total for the visa if you don't use an argent so I think it's well worth it. Also it is possible to complete the whole process without using an agent and you will find tons of help on here.

A LSD trip would probably be an awesome way of deciding whether or not you would like to make the move, although I wouldn't see it as an absolute necessity (some people on here may disagree). My girlfriend and I are planning on making the move early next year to Melbourne and neither of us have been anywhere in Aus before. The decision for us was based on the usual concerns of crime, raising a family here etc. We were also inspired to make a huge change and see more of the world after a lot of traveling around the US and Europe. I think at our age we're fortunate enough to be in a position to make big decisions like this and still have time to change plans if things don't work out as expected!

Good luck with the rest of your process and shout if you need anything!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Thanks for the responses all :)

Did most of you guys use agents or did you go through process on your own? I've seen that Migrate2Oz place has been mentioned a few times but adding that as another cost just for the peace of mind is still quite a big expense? :)

@DeepFriedMatt Looking at this thread alone I won't disagree with you there on the lots of help :)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

We didn't use an agent as we felt that our circumstances were straight forward enough to be able to manage ourselves. We have friends with the exact same situation as us who did use an agent (Migrate2Oz) who are in the same stage of the process as us now (waiting for a CO).

So personally I don't think there are huge pros or cons to using an agent. Like you said it's about weighing up the cost vs. the benefit of the added peace of mind.

Edited by DeepFriedMatt
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

×
×
  • Create New...